My writing about Genealogy My writing about Psychology My writing about Meat
Karl Lueger vs Sigmund Freud: A Disturbing Contrast in Vienna’s Legacies

Karl Lueger vs Sigmund Freud: A Disturbing Contrast in Vienna’s Legacies

For most of my week in Vienna, my experience of the city was so positive as to be a bit surreal.  I remembered Vienna from the early 1970s – the only time I’d visited before – as being gloomy and dour.

I also imagined that, given what I’d learned over the last few years about my family’s history, I would be coping with a lot of difficult emotions.

Not so.

Breakfast buffet at the wonderful Hotel Harmonie. What's not to like about Vienna?

Breakfast buffet at the wonderful Hotel Harmonie. What’s not to like about Vienna?

The city, several residents told me, has changed dramatically since the Iron Curtain fell in 1989. It wasn’t my imagination that Vienna used to be depressing when it was backed up against depressing Communist countries, they said, or that it has since shared in the tourist bounty that resulted from the area’s opening up.

In fact, that’s pretty much how I felt, like an appreciative tourist, visiting one of the world’s great cities, indulging in its famous indulgences. Even when I was taking pictures of my family’s former properties or visiting the graveyard where several members are buried (theoretically), I felt distanced from any negative feelings. I was looking at ordinary lives (and deaths), not thinking about 1938 and the Anschluss. I had no reason to.

Except on my first day in the city, and I avoided thinking about that. Until now.

Who the Heck Is Karl Lueger, Anyway?

A bit of background.

Until I began researching Vienna and my family history, I had never heard of Karl Lueger. But his name kept cropping up in my research. A mayor at the turn of the 20th century, he is known primarily for two things: Transforming Vienna into a modern city and being a virulent antisemite.

Karl Lueger at a ball in Vienna City Hall 1904, by Wilhelm Gause, Historical Museum of the City of Vienna, via Wikimedia Commons

Karl Lueger at a ball in Vienna City Hall 1904, by Wilhelm Gause, Historical Museum of the City of Vienna, via Wikimedia Commons

How antisemitic was he? So antisemitic that the Emperor Franz Josef I, who was friendly to the Jews, would not approve his election to mayor for two years.  So antisemitic that Hitler cited him as an inspiration for his own views in Mein Kampf.

At least that’s how many historians view it. But the Encyclopedia Britannica, which I’d always considered a respectable source, sees it a bit differently:

Lueger, from a working-class family, studied law at the University of Vienna. Elected to the capital’s municipal council as a liberal in 1875, he soon became popular for his exposure of corruption. Though he was not himself a violent anti-Semite and regarded German nationalism with skeptical antipathy, Lueger did not hesitate to exploit the prevalent anti-Semitic and nationalistic currents in Vienna for his own demagogic purposes. 

and

A believer in the equality of all nationalities in the multinational Habsburg monarchy, Lueger opposed Austro-Hungarian dualism and advocated a federal state. When the Christian Social Party won two-thirds of the seats in the Viennese municipal council in 1895, he was elected mayor; but the emperor, Francis Joseph I, regarding Lueger as a social revolutionary, refused to confirm his appointment for two years.

Emphasis mine.

So let me get this straight, Encyclopedia Britannica. Karl Lueger wasn’t really an antisemite — he only played one on TV because it was popular — or he was okay because he wasn’t a violent antisemite; he only incited violence with his rhetoric. And although he was an antisemite, he believed in the equality of all nationalities (except for Jews, who aren’t a nationality. Or a race. Or something). And the only reason that the imperialist emperor Franz Joseph didn’t confirm his appointment was because Lueger was a social revolutionary, not because he was a virulent antisemite who inspired racial hatred. Did I interpret that correctly?

It is noted by apologists that Lueger had many Jewish friends. Lueger’s cynical response to people who mentioned this to him is often attributed to Hitler: “I determine who is a Jew.”

Doktor-Karl-Lueger-Platz

Doktor Karl Lueger Platz So I was a bit shocked when, emerging from a central U-Bahn station, Stubentor, I saw a directional sign for Doktor-Karl-Lueger-Platz. Huh? Yup, close to the center of town, near the popular restaurant to which I was headed, Plachutta, is a plaza named for the man who inspired Hitler.

The fallback rationale is always that he did so much for Vienna that he can be forgiven for this one flaw. Yes, and dictator Francisco Franco got the trains in Spain to run on time. Karl Lueger statue in Karl Lueger Plaza But wait, some will say. An important street in Vienna was stripped of its Karl Lueger-ness not long ago. This is true. According to an April 2012 article in The Guardian:

… 78 years after a portion of the main belt of boulevards that encircles the city centre was named the Karl Lueger Ring, the streets signs are getting a makeover.

Last week the coalition of social democrats and Greens running the Austrian capital decided to rename the 600-metre stretch of the Ringstrasse bearing Lueger’s name, triggering a row about whitewashing history, political correctness, and Vienna’s often difficult attempts to deal with a troubled past.

But as the article also points out, near the University of Vienna “a large statue of the mayor dubbed the founder of modern antisemitism still stands proudly. The city government said there were no plans to make any other changes.”

Here’s a picture of the statue that stands near the university. Karl Lueger statue near the University of Vienna

[Note: Both of these photographs were taken by the author of the excellent post on Karl Lueger and Vienna in the Wanderlust für Wien blog.]

Where Is Herr-Professor-Sigmund-Freudplatz?

Which brings me to one of my favorite Viennese semites — outside of my family members, of course — Sigmund Freud. What about his legacy in Vienna?

Amazingly, there is no street named for Sigmund Freud in Vienna, and no major plaza, just a park near the university better known for being backed up against the impressive Votive Church than for its association with Freud.

Would Sigmund Freud approve of a park named for him that didn't allow dogs? I think not.

Would Sigmund Freud approve of a park named for him that didn’t allow dogs? I think not.

And, yes, a plaza named for Freud is in the works for 2015, but it is neither near the center of town, nor named for Sigmund alone. In front of the new campus building for the Sigmund Freud Private University (note: “private,” as in no municipal funding) in the Prater–the park known for its Ferris wheel, the Reisenrad–there is a plan to create a Freudplatz.

From the press release on the site from the Vienna City Council:

Freud Square commemorates in equal parts two luminaries of psychoanalysis — physician and psychoanalysis founder Sigmund Freud as well as his daughter, Anna Freud, who made exceptional contributions to the field of child psychoanalysis. Originally designed as “Sigmund Freud Square,” the present solution now takes into account both of these important personalities thanks to the initiative of the Executive City Councilor for Cultural Affairs and Science.

Solution? What was the problem?

I have it on good authority that this is an actual case of political correction run amok–as opposed to the political correctness that putatively occurred when the name of Karl Lueger Ring was changed. That is, the city said there were not enough streets and plazas named for women in Vienna, so a compromise was to name the plaza for both Freuds.

Now if there were an abundance of streets and plazas named for Sigmund, this might makes sense; I’m a feminist, and am all for recognizing women. Anna Freud was an important one. But first give her father his due, solo.

Of course, maybe this isn’t a case of political correctness, but antisemitism. Or maybe embarrassment over it. After all, Freud had to flee Vienna when he was an old man, one celebrated in the rest of the world but reviled as a Jew while the Nazis were greeted with cheers in Vienna in 1938. Freud finally decided to leave after Anna was detained overnight by the Nazis.

Take your pick of the reason that Anna and Sigmund Freud will be relegated to a twofer in Freudplatz.

And Where Is the Statue of Freud?

So… two grand, full-size statues of Karl Lueger, of whom almost no one outside Vienna or people doing research into the city has heard, and how many dedicated to Freud? None. Nada. Zilch.

There is a single bust of Freud in a “public” place, the University of Vienna. I found it–with the help of a guide–hiding behind some scaffolding in a row of undistinguished busts. Freud is not even in the center.

The very-difficult-to-find Sigmund Freud bust at the University of Vienna

The very-difficult-to-find Sigmund Freud bust at the University of Vienna

As it happens, a statue of Freud by sculptor Oskar Nemon was commissioned in 1936 by the city but was never cast in Vienna. It was, however, cast in London, where it stands in front of the Tavistock Clinic, and smaller versions of it exist in New York and Boston. freudandnemon-001 The plaster version, seen above with sculptor Oscar Nemon, still exists in London. It could be cast and erected in Vienna, perhaps in front of Freud Plaza where, rumor has it, there will be a statue.

Unless the city decides it needs a statue of Anna too. Then all bets are off.

More
Dueling Desserts, Plaster Poets, & Sigmund Freud: Vienna’s Cafe Culture

Dueling Desserts, Plaster Poets, & Sigmund Freud: Vienna’s Cafe Culture

I’ve touched on the fact that my family members dabbled in sweets as well as meats in my last two posts, which involved my cousin Curt Allina, who lived across the street from Sigmund Freud and who later put the heads on PEZ. But the Kornmehl family also had a direct connection with a quintessentially VienneseContinue Reading »

More Amazing Austrian Inventions! PEZ & Freud, Revisited

More Amazing Austrian Inventions! PEZ & Freud, Revisited

Mea culpa. In my last post, I talked about my cousin Curt Allina, who lived across the street from Freud when he was a boy and who has been credited with putting the heads on the PEZ dispensers. It was subsequently pointed out to me that, in the context of that discussion, I mistakenly identified the following itemContinue Reading »

Fleischhauers, Freud & Pez: Vienna’s Famed Berggasse

Fleischhauers, Freud & Pez: Vienna’s Famed Berggasse

I was in Vienna’s Jewish Records Office last week — was it really only last week? — looking to fill in some key bits of my family history. When archivist Irma Wulz showed me the marriage records of my grandparents, Hermann Rosenbaum and Ernestine Kornmehl, I wasn’t especially surprised to learn that the wedding witnesses had been David Schmerling, Ernestine’s brother-in-law and also her first cousin, as wellContinue Reading »

Vienna Public Transit: A (Rather Wordy) Photo Essay

Vienna Public Transit: A (Rather Wordy) Photo Essay

This will shock and amaze all who know me and my tendency to take terrible pictures/break cameras but I didn’t do too badly this time, so I thought I’d post a few photo essays rather than try to write up all my experiences more formally. We’ll see. I suspect there will be more words than pictures, inContinue Reading »

Cemetery Schlepping in Vienna: A Shaggy Deer Story

Cemetery Schlepping in Vienna: A Shaggy Deer Story

I like cemeteries, especially big sprawling ones with famous people buried in them. It’s always interesting to see different forms of remembrance and, for the most part, they are quiet, park-like places to stroll and contemplate mortality. Or dinner. Having visited Karl Marx and George Eliot in London’s Highgate, Oscar Wilde, Edith Piaf and JimContinue Reading »

Live from Vienna….It’s Saturday Night!

Live from Vienna….It’s Saturday Night!

I’ve been in Vienna three days now…wait, make that four. As you may have suspected, none of the dire things I was worried about came to pass. I got an aisle seat on my overnight flight. I couldn’t sleep anyway, but not because I was worried about climbing over someone to go to the bathroom.Continue Reading »

Confessions of a Travel-Challenged Travel Writer

Confessions of a Travel-Challenged Travel Writer

I have never been very good at the travel part of being a travel writer. As I’ve mentioned, I was primarily a travel journalist before I got a dog and became a dog writer and then found out that I was the great niece of Sigmund Freud’s butcher and started this blog. That biographical tidbit wasn’t especially relevant–until now,Continue Reading »

Inspiring My Vienna Visit: A Talk About Freud & Oscar Nemon

Inspiring My Vienna Visit: A Talk About Freud & Oscar Nemon

Several people have asked: What finally spurred you to visit Vienna this  June? Good question. I’ve been wanting to go for more than 2½ years, ever since I found out about the connection between my great uncle, Siegmund Kornmehl, and Vienna’s Sigmund Freud Museum, but had been dragging my heels. Money, ambivalence, pet care…I always had an excuse not to go. With the needContinue Reading »

The Harmonie Vienna: Seven Reasons It’s My Dream Hotel

The Harmonie Vienna: Seven Reasons It’s My Dream Hotel

I just got word of where I’ll be bunking during my upcoming trip to Austria, thanks to the Vienna Tourist Board: The Harmonie Vienna. As a travel writer, I’ve been fortunate enough to stay in some of the world’s top hotels and resorts. But I can’t recall a place that was a better fit for me, personally, since…well,Continue Reading »