A Kosher Meat Monopoly

I come from a long line of butchers, and not just Siegmund Kornmehl, the great uncle whose shop Sigmund Freud’s wife patronized. My mother used to talk about her butcher uncles, plural, and now I know for a fact that Rudolf and Martin Kornmehl practiced the trade along with their brother Siegmund; Martin’s sons George and Hans were butchers too. My great grandfather Heinrich — Siegmund, Martin and Rudolf’s father — was also  in the meat profession. The tombstone of his wife, Chaye Henriette Kornmehl, says she is a Fleischhauersgattin—butcher’s wife.

I know too that the brothers Kornmehl had multiple shops and supplied meat to a variety of Jewish organizations in Vienna.

Which leads to several questions.

Did my relatives have a kosher meat monopoly in Austria’s capital, an all-beef-sausage syndicate?

And what did it mean to be a butcher in fin-de-siecle Vienna? I don’t visualize a scene from Sinclair Lewis’s The Jungle but I have no image to replace it. Did a kosher butcher personally supervise the ritual slaughter? What was it like to cut meat all day and go to the opera at night? Was it a trade that carried more of a stigma than baker or candlestick maker?

And then there are the questions about the diet of Siegmund Kornmehl’s most famous customer. Records show that Freud ate meat every day. In what dishes? And why, if he was so anti-religion, did he eat kosher meat?

But I don’t intend to focus solely on the distant past in the Meat category. One of my writing specialties is dining but I haven’t had an outlet to muse on such topics as Temple Grandin and humane slaughterhouses, the comparative ethics of meat eating or the ridiculousness of banning foie gras. Look for them here, along with the stories of several meat-related epiphanies I’ve experienced.

Learn more about Genealogy


Learn more about Psychology


See My Family Trees

8 Responses to Meat

  1. A lot to think about. I’m getting hungry already. Glad your comment section is restored. Now can we have a place on the front page to subscribe to the posts?

    • Edie Jarolim says:

      I admit I’ve been craving hamburgers a lot since I started writing this blog. As for the subscriptions — how about all the buttons under “Connect” in the right and the “subscribe by email” option? Or do you mean individual posts?

  2. […] forced closure of the Vienna meat markets of the Kornmehl family by the Nazis marked the end of an era for the Kornmehl butchers. But not for long.  Twenty years […]

  3. […] Meat Musings: Why Foie Gras Bans Are FoolishPosted on September 9, 2012 by Edie Jarolim It’s a good thing I’m not a vegetarian. […]

  4. […] All three males of the eight Kornmehl siblings were butchers. What were the occupations of the five brothers-in-law who were not in the meat trade? How would […]

  5. […] Butcher Power! The Vienna Meat CliquePosted on October 8, 2012 by Edie Jarolim I’ve been trying to imagine what the life of a butcher was like in Vienna in the late 1800s and early 1900s, when my mother’s uncles, the Kornmehl brothers, were in the meat business. […]

  6. […] 3. Wie war es, als koscherer Metzger um die Jahrhundertwende in Wien zu leben (Fleisch) […]

  7. […] maintained at least some kosher principals in the household, in all likelihood without his knowledge13. Even though machine matzos were the new thing in turn-of-the-century Vienna, they were banished by […]

Leave a reply

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

My recent posts about Meat ↓
Rolled Beef, Wolf Blitzer & More Buffalo Kornmehls

Rolled Beef, Wolf Blitzer & More Buffalo Kornmehls

In my backlog of unfinished posts, this one — started in November 2019 — seemed the most timely for this pandemic Passover. It’s partly elegiac, which fits the current mood, but it’s also about finding new family. And about endurance. A deli-denying newscaster plays a part in the narrative too. Fake news!  Rolled Beef, ReduxContinue Reading

A Meaty Heritage

A Meaty Heritage

It’s day 16 of the Family History Writing Challenge and I’m feeling grateful that I’m not a vegetarian. It’s bad enough to have to face the dire fates of various family members while exploring the past; I’m not sure I could cope with feeling guilty about the fact that they were butchers. My ambivalence –nay,Continue Reading

A Fowl Business: Another Kornmehl Family Butcher Shop (& Freud’s Likely Aversion to It)

A Fowl Business: Another Kornmehl Family Butcher Shop (& Freud’s Likely Aversion to It)

This is Day 11 of the Family History Writing Challenge, 2018 In my last post, I outlined several questions arising from Adolf Schweizer’s emigration form that I was hoping to tackle. The first one related to the nature of the butcher shop that Adolf owned–or worked in. It was very easily answered. In the sectionContinue Reading

Asser Levy: America’s First Kosher Butcher

Asser Levy: America’s First Kosher Butcher

Knowing of my interest in the the history of Jewish butchers, the ever-helpful Philip Trauring of the Blood and Frogs Jewish genealogy blog sent me a link to a post from New York’s Tenement Museum, “Keeping Kosher in 17th Century New York:” November 15th, 1660 was, by any means, a normal day in the smallContinue Reading

Rolled Beef: “The Giant Panda of Deli Meats”

Rolled Beef: “The Giant Panda of Deli Meats”

I learned a great deal about the late Nathan Kornmehl from the many testimonials that were sent to the memorial page of this blog. By all accounts, he was a generous, kind man, someone who didn’t let the tremendous adversity he faced from the Nazis make him angry or bitter. I also learned that hisContinue Reading

Freud’s Butcher, Year One: Five Highlights

Freud’s Butcher, Year One: Five Highlights

It’s hard to believe that a year has passed since I wrote my first post here, a speculation on whether Freud ate kosher. It’s been quite the wild ride since then — a statement that might surprise those who think that genealogy is boring. But if you use the term family history  — emphasis onContinue Reading